Italy’s data protection watchdog has imposed an €805 million penalty on Meta after finding that Facebook accessed Android users’ photos, videos and related metadata without obtaining sufficiently specific consent. The decision puts renewed pressure on how technology companies request permissions and handle personal information stored on smartphones.
A feature designed to make sharing photos on Facebook easier has landed Meta with an €805 million fine in Italy.
The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as Garante Privacy, announced on November 14, 2026, that it had sanctioned Meta Platforms Ireland Limited over the way Facebook accessed photos, videos and associated metadata stored on Android users’ smartphones.
The investigation focused on a Facebook feature called “Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook”. Introduced in 2023, the feature suggests photos and videos from a user’s phone gallery while they browse the platform, offering content that they might want to share as posts.
According to the regulator, the problem was not simply that Facebook requested access to a smartphone gallery. It was how that access was requested, explained and activated.
The Garante found that Facebook relied on a single permission covering the entire application and several functions with different purposes. Before requesting authorisation, the app displayed a generic message asking users to enable “other features”. That wording did not adequately explain that granting permission would also enable gallery suggestions.
The regulator also found that the feature was switched on by default.
Once the relevant permission was granted, the application could potentially read the entire photo archive stored on the device, on an ongoing basis. The authority said neither users nor the regulator could independently verify which information was actually being used.
The investigation began in July 2025 following a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre and included a technical assessment conducted by the Italian authority.
The scale of the issue was significant. The Garante estimated that approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were involved.
Why the Regulator Considered This a Privacy Violation
At the centre of the decision is Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the European ePrivacy Directive.
The provision protects information stored on users’ devices and requires free and informed consent before applications access that information, subject to applicable legal exceptions.
The Garante emphasised an important distinction: access to information stored on a smartphone requires valid consent regardless of whether the information is subsequently transmitted elsewhere or whether a user can demonstrate that they suffered actual harm.
In other words, the issue is not limited to whether a company collects, uploads or sells personal information. The way an application accesses information already stored on a person’s device is itself subject to privacy protections.
This is an important principle for the wider technology industry. Smartphones increasingly contain personal photographs, private conversations, location information, documents and other sensitive material. An application permission should not become a blanket authorisation for unrelated features simply because they are bundled into the same software.
For users, meaningful consent means understanding what an application wants to access, why it needs that access and how to withdraw permission.
For technology companies, it means designing permission requests around clearly defined purposes rather than relying on broad or ambiguous notices.
Meta’s Jurisdictional Argument Rejected
Meta challenged the Italian authority’s jurisdiction, arguing that the matter should fall under the responsibility of Ireland’s data protection authority, where Meta Platforms Ireland Limited is established.
The Garante rejected that argument.
Its reasoning was that the ePrivacy rules applicable to the case do not provide for the GDPR’s familiar one-stop-shop mechanism, under which a lead supervisory authority can coordinate certain cross-border GDPR investigations.
This distinction matters for multinational technology companies operating across the European Union. Compliance with the GDPR does not automatically resolve every obligation arising under separate national laws implementing the ePrivacy Directive.
The decision reinforces the need for companies to consider the full regulatory framework applicable to their products, rather than treating cross-border privacy compliance as a single-authority exercise.
Was Meta Using the Photos to Train Artificial Intelligence?
The distinction is important, particularly at a time when the use of personal data in artificial intelligence has become a major privacy concern.
The Garante explicitly stated that its investigation did not concern the potential use of gallery content to train artificial intelligence models, an allegation Meta denies.
The authority also said it reserves the right to conduct a separate assessment of another feature introduced in 2026, which allows cloud processing of gallery content.
That means the €805 million penalty should not be presented as a finding that Meta used these photographs to train AI systems. The case concerns access to users’ device galleries without sufficiently specific and informed consent.
The separate cloud-processing feature could become the subject of further regulatory scrutiny, but no conclusion about its legality was established in this decision.
What Meta Must Change Within 60 Days
The Italian regulator has ordered Meta to make changes to the Facebook feature within 60 days.
The requirements include:
- Separate consent: Meta must introduce a specific consent request for the gallery-suggestion feature, clearly explaining its purpose and the fact that it requires access to users’ photo galleries.
- Clear user information: Users must be informed about how the feature works and how they can disable it.
- Disabled by default: The feature must remain switched off by default, including for users who previously granted the broader permission.
- Reporting obligations: Meta must inform the authority within 30 days about the initiatives it has started and provide details of the measures adopted within 90 days.
If the 60-day deadline expires without the required changes, the feature cannot be activated for users who have not provided valid consent.
The regulator also explained the factors behind the penalty.
These included the large number of people involved, the duration of the infringement, a previous decision against the company in 2019 and what the authority described as limited cooperation during the investigation.
Changes introduced by Meta after the original complaint were considered mitigating factors, although the Garante regarded them as late and insufficiently comprehensive because they applied only to users who updated their applications.
The €805 million penalty represents approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue.
Why This Decision Matters Beyond Italy
Although the case concerns Android users in Italy, its implications extend well beyond the country’s borders.
Modern applications frequently request access to device resources such as cameras, microphones, contacts, location services and photo libraries. These permissions support legitimate functionality, but they can also create privacy risks when users are not given a clear explanation of what they are authorising.
The Italian decision sends a strong message to application developers, technology providers and digital platforms: technical permission granted through an operating system should not automatically be treated as informed consent for every feature within an application.
For businesses, this is particularly relevant when developing mobile applications, deploying employee-facing software or integrating third-party services that process personal information.
Organizations operating in the Middle East and Africa should also pay attention. Although the decision applies to the specific Italian regulatory framework, the underlying questions around transparency, purpose limitation, consent and access to personal information are relevant to privacy programmes across the region.
In the UAE, for example, organizations subject to the UAE Personal Data Protection Law should ensure that their applications and digital services comply with applicable requirements concerning personal data processing, transparency and lawful grounds for processing. Other markets across Africa have also introduced or strengthened data protection frameworks.
For technology companies expanding internationally, privacy compliance should be considered during product design, not added as an afterthought once a regulator raises concerns.
Ten Lessons for Organizations and Security Teams
The Meta case provides a useful opportunity for organizations to review how their own applications and digital services access personal information.
Security, privacy and development teams should consider the following measures:
1. Audit application permissions. Review all permissions requested by corporate mobile applications, including access to photos, videos, contacts, microphones, cameras and location information. Identify permissions that are broader than necessary.
2. Apply the principle of least privilege. Applications should only receive the minimum level of access required to deliver their intended functionality. Avoid requesting unrestricted access when a more limited permission is available.
3. Separate consent by purpose. Do not bundle unrelated processing activities into one generic consent request. Explain each purpose clearly and obtain the appropriate consent where required.
4. Disable optional features by default. Features that access sensitive personal information should not automatically become active without an appropriate legal basis and clear user choice.
5. Improve privacy notices. Replace vague messages with straightforward explanations that tell users what information is accessed, why it is needed and how it will be used.
6. Review third-party applications and SDKs. Software development kits and integrated third-party services can introduce additional data-access activities. Review their permissions, data flows and contractual privacy obligations.
7. Implement privacy by design. Include privacy and security requirements from the earliest stages of application development, rather than treating them as final deployment checks.
8. Monitor data access and processing. Maintain appropriate technical records and monitoring mechanisms to understand which applications access sensitive information and whether that access matches the declared purpose.
9. Establish clear consent withdrawal mechanisms. Users should be able to change their preferences and withdraw consent where applicable without unnecessary complexity.
10. Train development, IT and privacy teams. Ensure employees understand data protection responsibilities, application permissions, secure development practices and the consequences of non-compliance. Regular cybersecurity and privacy awareness programmes can help reduce preventable risks.
Organizations can strengthen these capabilities through dedicated cybersecurity training and awareness programmes, alongside broader information security and data protection services.
The Bigger Picture: Privacy Must Be Built Into Technology
The €805 million fine is a reminder that convenience cannot come at the expense of transparency and user control.
Features that make digital platforms easier to use may appear harmless, but when they require access to personal information stored on individual devices, the responsibilities of the technology provider become much greater.
For the wider technology industry, the message is straightforward: users should know what they are authorising, why their information is needed and how they can remain in control.
The decision also highlights the growing importance of privacy governance alongside traditional cybersecurity controls. Protecting information is not only about preventing external attackers from accessing systems. It is also about ensuring that legitimate applications and services handle personal information responsibly.
As regulators continue to scrutinise how technology companies collect and process personal data, organizations that build transparency, consent management and privacy by design into their operations will be better positioned to maintain user trust and meet regulatory expectations.
Final takeaway: Meta’s €805 million penalty is about more than a Facebook feature. It is a significant reminder that access to personal information must be transparent, justified and properly authorised.
Stay informed. Stay secure.
Official source: Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante Privacy), November 14, 2026. Facebook: The Garante fines Meta €805 million.




